How to test a tattoo before you get it: temporary tattoos, henna and try-on apps
Seven ways to try a design on before it's permanent — and one popular shortcut that can leave you with a lifelong allergy.
A tattoo is built to outlast your taste. Laser removal takes many sessions, and a cover-up limits what can come next — our guide to removal and cover-ups explains both. Yet most of what people come to dislike about a tattoo — the size, the spot, the design itself — can be tested beforehand. Each method below answers a different question and none answers all of them, so it's worth combining two or three.
Seven ways to try it on
On paper and in pen
The cheapest test is also the most underrated. Measure the spot, print the design at that exact size — check the print dialog is set to 100%, not “fit to page” — then cut it out and tape it on. Look at it in a mirror, from across the room and in a photo. A design that's perfect at phone size often turns out too small to read, or too big for the spot, at actual size.
Paper stays flat, though, and bodies don't. Drawing the outline straight onto the skin — with eyeliner or a skin-marking pen, not a solvent permanent marker — shows how it wraps around a forearm or shifts when you bend an elbow, twist a wrist or lift an arm.
On a screen: try-on apps
A try-on app does in seconds what paper does in an afternoon, and for many designs at once: different sizes, spots and versions on your own body, with nothing touching your skin. That makes it the right tool while you're still choosing — before you print, pay for anything or book.
INKterest is built for exactly this. It shows a design live through the camera in 2D, or follows your body's curves in 3D, and A vs B puts two designs, sizes or spots side by side on the same photo. Designs can come from the built-in Pinterest browser, with about 250 tattoo styles and themes, or from your own photos, and Lettering sets a name, a date or a quote in one of 59 tattoo fonts. Be clear about what any app can show: placement, size and proportion, yes; how the line work will look, how the ink settles in your skin and how it heals, no — those belong to the artist and to your body.
Living with it: printed temporary tattoos
The real question is often not “does it look good?” but “will I still like seeing it every day?”. A temporary tattoo printed from your own design answers it: wear it to work, to the gym, past the bathroom mirror every morning. According to the U.S. Food and Drug Administration, these decal-type tattoos last from a day to a week or more.
They're not risk-free. The FDA has received reports of reactions to some decal tattoos, the colours in them must be approved for use on skin, and the agency keeps import alerts in place for some temporary tattoos. Buy from a seller that lists ingredients, and do as the FDA suggests: try one on a less conspicuous part of your body before you wear it anywhere that matters. The look is a compromise too — glossier and flatter than ink.
Natural henna and jagua
Henna, the powdered leaf of Lawsonia inermis, leaves a red-orange to brown stain that fades in two to six weeks, according to a 2020 dermatology review. A full review of its side-effects found red henna generally safe, with allergy rare — though it can be dangerous for children with G6PD deficiency, an inherited enzyme disorder. Two caveats. In the U.S., henna is approved only as a hair dye, not for use on skin. And what's sold as henna often isn't: when Spanish chemists analysed 14 commercial henna tattoo products, only one contained lawsone, the pigment that gives henna its colour.
Jagua comes closer to the real thing. It's made from the fruit of Genipa americana, and its key ingredient, genipin, is colourless until it reacts with the skin and turns it blue-black — the closest a temporary tattoo usually gets to the look of black ink. Jagua is sold as natural and PPD-free, and analyses have found no PPD in it. But natural isn't the same as safe: genipin itself can cause allergic contact dermatitis. In one well-documented case, a woman who repeatedly applied a jagua tattoo dye advertised as “completely natural and 100% safe” developed an allergy to genipin within six weeks. Try a small spot first — and know that a test spot may not catch an allergy that builds up with repeated use.
The one to skip: “black henna”
Real henna is never black. On its own it gives a brown, orange-brown or reddish-brown tint, the FDA notes, so a black “henna” tattoo — the kind offered at beach stalls, markets and festivals — has something added. That something is usually a coal-tar hair dye containing p-phenylenediamine (PPD), and sometimes it's simply hair dye with no henna at all. PPD is not permitted in products for the skin in the U.S. or in the EU.
The doses are far above anything allowed in hair dye. The mixture behind one patient's allergic reaction held 15.7% PPD; all 25 black henna mixtures bought from tattoo shops in Turkey contained it, at 3.37% to 51.6%.
The reaction is delayed, which is why people don't connect it to the tattoo. In someone the tattoo itself has sensitised, it appears four to fourteen days later, within one to three days in someone already allergic: redness, swelling, blisters, often in the exact shape of the design. As it heals it can leave darker skin or a white outline of the tattoo, and keloid scars have been reported.
The bigger cost comes later. Once sensitised, people can react — sometimes severely — to hair dyes, and often cross-react to some textile dyes, local anaesthetics and rubber chemicals. It's a big enough problem that EU law makes every hair dye pack with PPD carry the warning “Temporary ‘black henna’ tattoos may increase your risk of allergy”, and tell anyone who has reacted to one not to colour their hair. Children are often the ones affected: in a 2015 British Skin Foundation survey, four in ten dermatologists had treated reactions to black henna tattoos, and one in twenty said more than 80% of the cases they'd seen were in under-16s. About half the patients had got theirs outside the EU.
So: turn down any black “henna”, and be wary of very dark brown too — the FDA warns that even brown products sold as henna can contain ingredients added to darken them. If you've already reacted to one, see a doctor, and tell your hairdresser and any doctor treating you that you may be allergic to PPD.
A trial plan that works
- Shortlist on screen. Try several designs, sizes and spots in a try-on app and keep the two or three you keep coming back to.
- Check the true size. Print the favourite at 100% and tape it on, or draw it on in skin-safe pen.
- Live with it. Wear a printed temporary tattoo or a jagua version for a week or so, after testing a small spot first.
- Wait. Look again in a month. If you still love it, that's a good sign — and if you're wondering who ends up regretting a tattoo, see what the research says.
- Use the stencil. Before the first line, most artists put a stencil of the design on your skin. Look at it properly, move around, and ask for it to be moved or resized if it isn't right — it's your last free change.
What no trial can show you
Every method here tests the idea, not the tattoo. How crisp the lines are, how the ink settles and how it ages in your skin depend on the artist and on you — so look at photos of an artist's healed work, not just fresh pieces. And plan for the parts no preview covers: how much it hurts where you want it, how that spot heals and what it will cost.
- U.S. Food and Drug Administration. Temporary Tattoos, Henna/Mehndi, and “Black Henna”: Fact Sheet. Content current as of 15 October 2024.
- Atwater A. R., Bembry R., Reeder M. Tattoo Hypersensitivity Reactions: Inky Business. Cutis, 2020; 106(2): 64–67.
- de Groot A. C. Side-effects of henna and semi-permanent ‘black henna’ tattoos: a full review. Contact Dermatitis, 2013; 69(1): 1–25.
- Rubio L., Lores M., Garcia-Jares C. Monitoring of Natural Pigments in Henna and Jagua Tattoos for Fake Detection. Cosmetics, 2020; 7(4): 74.
- Bircher A. J. et al. Allergic contact dermatitis caused by a new temporary blue-black tattoo dye — sensitization to genipin from jagua (Genipa americana L.) fruit extract. Contact Dermatitis, 2017; 77(6): 374–378.
- Brancaccio R. R. et al. Identification and quantification of para-phenylenediamine in a temporary black henna tattoo. American Journal of Contact Dermatitis, 2002; 13(1): 15–18.
- Aktas Sukuroglu A., Battal D., Burgaz S. Monitoring of Lawsone, p-phenylenediamine and heavy metals in commercial temporary black henna tattoos sold in Turkey. Contact Dermatitis, 2017; 76(2): 89–95.
- DermNet. Black henna tattoo reaction. Updated November 2019.
- British Skin Foundation. The dangers of ‘black henna’ temporary tattoos (survey of 244 dermatologists, July 2015).
- Regulation (EC) No 1223/2009 on cosmetic products, Annex III, entry 8a (p-phenylenediamine): maximum concentration and label warnings for hair dyes.